Detection of a very serious error in the paper: 'On identifiability of nonlinear ODE models and applications in viral dynamics'
| Autor: | Martinelli, Agostino |
|---|---|
| Rok vydání: | 2023 |
| Předmět: | |
| Druh dokumentu: | Working Paper |
| Popis: | This erratum highlights a very serious error in a paper published by SIAM Review in 2011. The error is in Section 6.2 of [1]. It is very important to notify this error because of the following two reasons: (i) [1] is one of the most cited contributions in the field of identifiability of viral dynamics models, and (ii)the error is relevant because, as a result of it, a very popular viral model (perhaps the most popular in the field of HIV dynamics) has been classified as identifiable. In contrast, three of its parameters are not identifiable, even locally. This erratum first proves the non uniqueness of the three unidentifiable parameters by exhibiting infinitely many distinct but indistinguishable values of them. The non uniqueness is even local. Then, this erratum details the error made by the authors of [1] which produced the claimed (but false) local identifiability of all the model parameters. Comment: SIAM review refuses to publish this erratum. This is in my opinion a very wrong decision which significantly deteriorates the rank of this journal. Or, even worse, this decision highlights an unfortunately low rank of this journal |
| Databáze: | arXiv |
| Externí odkaz: |
|