Reply to 'Comment on 'An Alternative Approach for the Determination of Mean Free Paths of Electron Scattering in Liquid Water Based on Experimental Data''

Autor: Schild, Axel, Peper, Michael, Perry, Conaill, Rattenbacher, Dominik, Wörner, Hans Jakob
Rok vydání: 2020
Předmět:
Druh dokumentu: Working Paper
Popis: In a recent comment, Ruth Signorell raises a number of issues that she considers to question the validity of our approach to determine mean free paths for electron scattering in liquid water and our comparison with the results on amorphous ice by Michaud, Wen, and Sanche. Here, we show that these critiques are unjustified, being either unfounded or based on misconceptions by the author of the comment. We nevertheless welcome the opportunity to further clarify certain aspects of our work that we did not discuss in detail in our letter.
Comment: The comment which is reply is referring to was rejected for publication, hence this reply will also not be published
Databáze: arXiv