| Popis: |
Differential use of communal (kindness, cooperation, morality) and agentic terms (competence, assertiveness, decisiveness) may reveal bias and has been extensively reported in letters of recommendation (LoR) for residency but letter writer factors have not been thoroughly studied. We estimate the association between use of agentic and communal language with letter writer and applicant characteristics.Retrospective review of LoR comparing 2 letters written for the same applicant. Applicant demographics and USMLE scores as well as letter writer demographics and academic/departmental rank were compared. Multilevel regression controlling for clustering of letters within applicant was performed.Single academic surgery residency program in a tertiary center.US medical students applying for categorical surgery residency.Applications of 667 US medical students (age 27.1, interquartile range [IQR] 26.2-28.6; female 340, 51%, white 337, 54.2%) were evaluated. Most commonly, letters writers were males (n = 1031, 77.3%), Full Professors (n = 660, 49.48%) and Department Chairs or Division Chiefs (n = 629, 47.151%). Overall, median bias score was 14.29 (interquartile range -4 to 33.33), indicating predominance of agentic terms. Applicant female gender (coef 3.64, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.33-6.96) and higher Step 1 USMLE scores (coef 0.12, 95% CI 0.0026-0.24) were associated with increased use of agentic terms. For letter writer characteristics, female (coef -4.23, 95% CI -8.14 to -0.32) and fewer years in practice (coef -0.32, 95% CI -0.48 to -0.16) were independent predictors of increased use of communal traits.Comparing 2 LoR written for the same applicant, male and more senior surgeons use more agentic language in their LoR as compared to female and younger surgeons. Increased use of communal language is expected as the pool of letter writers is diversified and reflects essential characteristics of contemporary surgeons. |
Full Text from ScienceDirect