A Call for Caution in Use of Pertussis Vaccine Effectiveness Studies to Estimate Waning Immunity: A Canadian Immunization Research Network Study
| Autor: | Salaheddin M. Mahmud, Frances B. Jamieson, Lawrence W. Svenson, Rachel D Savage, Steven J. Drews, Kimberley Simmonds, Natasha S. Crowcroft, Cynthia Chen, Shelley L. Deeks, Ye Li, Christopher M. Bell, Jeffrey C. Kwong, Kevin L Schwartz, Christiaan H. Righolt, Shelly Bolotin, Alex Marchand-Austin, Caitlin Johnson, Margaret L. Russell |
|---|---|
| Rok vydání: | 2019 |
| Předmět: |
Microbiology (medical)
Ontario Pertussis Vaccine medicine.medical_specialty Pediatrics business.industry Whooping Cough Public health Confounding Vaccination medicine.disease Comorbidity Clinical trial Major Articles and Commentaries Infectious Diseases Immunization Case-Control Studies medicine Pertussis vaccine Humans Waning immunity business medicine.drug |
| Zdroj: | Clin Infect Dis |
| ISSN: | 1537-6591 |
| Popis: | Background Vaccine effectiveness (VE) studies provide essential evidence on waning vaccine-derived immunity, a major threat to pertussis control. We evaluated how study design affects estimates by comparing 2 case-control studies conducted in Ontario, Canada. Methods We compared results from a test-negative design (TND) with a frequency-matched design (FMD) case-control study using pertussis cases from 2005–2015. In the first study, we identified test-negative controls from the public health laboratory that diagnosed cases and, in the second, randomly selected controls from patients attending the same physicians that reported cases, frequency matched on age and year. We compared characteristics of cases and controls using standardized differences. Results In both designs, VE estimates for the early years postimmunization were consistent with clinical trials (TND, 84%; FMD, 89% at 1–3 years postvaccination) but diverged as time since last vaccination increased (TND, 41%; FMD, 74% by 8 years postvaccination). Overall, we observed lower VE and faster waning in the TND than the FMD. In the TND but not FMD, controls differed from cases in important confounders, being younger, having more comorbidities, and higher healthcare use. Differences between the controls of each design were greater than differences between cases. TND controls were more likely to be unvaccinated or incompletely vaccinated than FMD controls (P Conclusions The FMD adjusted better for healthcare-seeking behavior than the TND. Duration of protection from pertussis vaccines is unclear because estimates vary by study design. Caution should be exercised by experts, researchers, and decision makers when evaluating evidence on optimal timing of boosters. |
| Databáze: | OpenAIRE |
| Externí odkaz: |
|