No privileged link between intentionality and causation: Generalizable effects of agency in language

Autor: Sehrang Joo, Sami Ryan Yousif, Fabienne Martin, Frank Keil, Joshua Knobe
Rok vydání: 2022
Předmět:
Zdroj: Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, vol 44, iss 44
Popis: Consider a causal claim like “Tom caused the train delay.” Previous research has shown that the extent to which Tom is seen to act intentionally (i.e., through his own agency) affects the extent to which people agree with this claim. But is this effect of perceived agency a unique phenomenon to causal judgments? Two experiments suggest this may not be the case. Study 1 finds that perceived agency affects people’s under- standing of both causal and non-causal events. Study 2 then finds that while perceptions of agency were similarly involved in people’s understanding of causal and non-causal events, they affected only cases where these events were brought about by animate agents (e.g., people). These results thus suggest that perceptions of agency may have a much more general influence in how people understand events involving agents, and therefore in how they understand the sentences that describe them. We discuss implications for causal cognition, broader research in agency, and the intersections between both and linguistics.
Databáze: OpenAIRE