Replications of fundamental research models in ultra high dilutions 1994 and 2015 - update on a bibliometric study

Autor: P.C. Endler, Sintia Mazon, Leoni Villano Bonamin, Paolo Bellavite, Tim Jäger
Přispěvatelé: Interuniv Coll Hlth & Dev Graz Castle Seggau, Univ Verona, Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp), Univ Witten Herdecke, Univ Bern, Univ Freiburg
Jazyk: angličtina
Rok vydání: 2015
Předmět:
Zdroj: Web of Science
Repositório Institucional da UNESP
Universidade Estadual Paulista (UNESP)
instacron:UNESP
ISSN: 1995-2015
DOI: 10.7892/boris.77836
Popis: Made available in DSpace on 2018-11-26T15:28:26Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 0 Previous issue date: 2015-10-01 Introduction: This paper focuses exclusively on experimental models with ultra high dilutions (i.e. beyond 10(-23)) that have been submitted to replication scrutiny. It updates previous surveys, considers suggestions made by the research community and compares the state of replication in 1994 with that in 2015. Methods: Following literature research, biochemical, immunological, botanical, cell biological and zoological studies on ultra high dilutions (potencies) were included. Reports were grouped into initial studies, laboratory-internal, multicentre and external replications. Repetition could yield either comparable, or zero, or opposite results. The null-hypothesis was that test and control groups would not be distinguishable (zero effect). Results: A total of 126 studies were found. From these, 28 were initial studies. When all 98 replicative studies were considered, 70.4% (i.e. 69) reported a result comparable to that of the initial study, 20.4% (20) zero effect and 9.2% (9) an opposite result. Both for the studies until 1994 and the studies 1995-2015 the null-hypothesis (dominance of zero results) should be rejected. Furthermore, the odds of finding a comparable result are generally higher than of finding an opposite result. Although this is true for all three types of replication studies, the fraction of comparable studies diminishes from laboratory-internal (total 82.9%) to multicentre (total 75%) to external (total 48.3%), while the fraction of opposite results was 4.9%, 10.7% and 13.8%. Furthermore, it became obvious that the probability of an external replication producing comparable results is bigger for models that had already been further scrutinized by the initial researchers. Conclusions: We found 28 experimental models which underwent replication. In total, 24 models were replicated with comparable results, 12 models with zero effect, and 6 models with opposite results. Five models were externally reproduced with comparable results. We encourage further replications of studies in order to learn more about the model systems used. Interuniv Coll Hlth & Dev Graz Castle Seggau, A-8042 Graz, Austria Univ Verona, I-37100 Verona, Italy Univ Estadual Paulista, Sao Paulo, Brazil Univ Witten Herdecke, Witten, Germany Univ Bern, Inst Complementary Med IKOM, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland Univ Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany Univ Estadual Paulista, Sao Paulo, Brazil
Databáze: OpenAIRE
Externí odkaz: