Reproducibility of Fluorescent Expression from Engineered Biological Constructs in E. coli

Autor: Jacob, Beal, Trac Haddock Angellii, Markus, Gershater, Kim de Mora, Meagan, Lizarazo, Jim, Hollenhorst, Randy, Rettberg, Philipp, Demling, Rene, Hanke, Michae, Osthegel, Anna, Schechtel, Suresh, Sudarsan, Arne, Zimmermann, Bartosz, Gabryelczyk, Martina, Ikonen, Minnamari, Salmela, Muradıye, Acar, Muhammed Fatih Aktas, Furkan, Bestepe, Furkan Sacit Ceylan, Sadık, Cigdem, Mikail, Dohan, Mustafa, Elitok, Mehmet, Gunduz, Esra, Gunduz, Omer Faruk Hatipoglu, Turan, Kaya, Orhan, Sayin, Safa, Tapan, Osman Faruk Tereci, Abdullah, Uçar, Mustafa, Yilmaz, Jeffrey, Barrick, Alex, Gutierrez, Dennis, Mishler, Jordan, Monk, Kate, Mortensen, Nathan, Shin, Ella, Watkins, Yintong, Chen, Yuji, Jin, Yuanjie, Shi, Haoqian Myelin Zhang, Bruno, Ono, Ieda Maria Martinez Paino, Lais, Ribovski, Ivan, Silva, Danilo Keiji Zampronio, Nils, Birkholz, Rudiger Frederik Busche, Oliver, Konzock, Steffen, Lippold, Carsten, Ludwig, Melanie, Philippi, Lukas, Platz, Christian, Sigismund, Susanne, Weber, Maren, Wehrs, Niels, Werchau, Anna, Wronska, Zen Zen Yen, Yash, Agarwal, Evan, Appleton, Douglas, Densmore, Ariela, Esmurria, Kathleen, Lewis, Alan, Pacheco, Marcel, Bruchez, Danielle, Peters, Cheryl, Telmer, Lena, Wang, Silvia Canas Duarte, Daniel Giraldo Perez, Camilo Gomez Garzon, Jorge Madrid Wolff, Nathaly Marin Medina, Valentina, Mazzanti, Laura Rodriguez Forero, Eitan, Scher, Robin, Dowell, Samantha, O’Hara, Cloe Simone Pogoda, Kendra, Shattuck, Ali, Altintas, Anne Pihl Bali, Rasmus, Bech, Anne, Egholm, Anne Sofie Laerke Hansen, Kristian, Jensen, Kristian Barreth Karlsen, Caroline, Mosbech, Sophia, Belkhelfa, Noemie, Berenger, Romain, Bodinier, Cecile, Jacry, Laura Matabishi Bibi, Pierre, Parutto, Julie, Zaworski, Andries de Vries, Freek de Wijs, Rick, Elbert, Lisa, Hielkema, Chandhuru, Jagadeesan, Bayu, Jayawardhana, Oscar, Kuipers, Anna, Lauxen, Thomas, Meijer, Sandra, Mous, Renske van Raaphorst, Aakanksha, Saraf, Otto, Schepers, Oscar, Smits, Jan Willem Veening, Ruud Detert Oude Weme, Lianne, Wieske, Catherine, Ainsworth, Xenia Spencer Milnes, Alejandro, Gómezávila, Eddie Cano Gamez, Ana Laura Torres Huerta, Carlos Alejandro Meza Ramirez, Philipp, Popp, Jara, Radeck, Anna, Sommer, Xiangkai, Li, Qi, Wu, Hongxia, Zhao, Ruixue, Zhao, Irem, Bastuzel, Yasemin, Ceyhan, Mayda, Gursel, Burak, Kizil, Ilkem, Kumru, Yasemin, Kuvvet, Helin, Tercan, Seniz, Yuksel, Luiza, Niyazmetova, Timothy, Ang, Lucas, Black, Ciaran, Kelly, George, Wadhams, Clovis, Basier, Urszula, Czerwinska, Cindy Suci Ananda, Muhammad Al Azhar, Adelia, Elviantari, Maya, Fitriana, Arief Budi Witarto, Yuliant, Jia Fangxing, Qingfeng, Hou, Wan, Pei, Chen, Rifei, Wang, Rong, Huang, Wei, Zhang, Yushan, Jianguo, He, Dengwen, Lai, Pai, Li, Jianheng, Liu, Chunyang, Ni, Qianbin, Zhang, Cinthya, Cadenas, Zardain Canabal, Eduardo J., Claudia Nallely Alonso Cantu, Mercedes Alejandra Vazquez Cantu, Eduardo Cepeda Canedo, Cesar Miguel Valdez Cordova, Jose Alberto de la Paz Espinosa, Carlos Enrique Alavez Garcia, Ana Laura Navarro Heredia, Adriana, Hernandez, Sebastian Valdivieso Jauregui, Eduardo Ramirez Montiel, Eduardo Serna Morales, Yamile Minerva Castellanos Morales, Omar Alonso Cantu Pena, Ramirez Rodríguez, Eduardo A., Elizabeth Vallejo Trejo, Jesus Gilberto Rodriguez Ceja, Jesus Eduardo Martinez Hernandez, Mario Alberto Pena Hernandez, Enrique Amaya Perez, Rebeca Paola Torres Ramirez, Cla, J., Martin, Hanzel, Sarah Mohand Said, Shihab, Sawar, Dylan, Siriwardena, Alex, Tzahristos, Nils, Anlind, Martin, Friberg, Erik, Gullberg, Stephanie, Herman, Dallin, Christensen, Sara, Gertsch, Cody, Maxfield, Charles, Miller, Ryan, Putman, Christine, Bauerl, Estelles Lopez, Lucia T., Estefania Huet Trujillo, Marta Vazquez Vilar, Marlène Sophie Birk, Nico, Claassens, Walter de Koster, Rik van Rosmalen, Wen Ying Wu, Sian, Davies, Dan, Goss, William, Rostain, Chelsey, Tye, Waqar, Yousaf, Natalie, Farny, Chloe, Lajeunesse, Alex, Turland, Chen, An, Jielin, Chen, Yahong, Chen, Zehua, Che, Baishan, Fang, Xiaotong, Fu, Xifeng, Guo, Yue, Jiang, Yiying, Lei, Jianqiao, Li, Zhe, Li, Chang, Liu, Weibing, Liu, Yang, Li, Yizhu, Lv, Qingyu, Ruan, Yue, Su, Chun, Tang, Yushen, Wang, Fan, Wu, Xiaoshan, Yan, Ruihua, Zhang, Tangduo, Zhang, Farren, Isaacs, Ariel Leyva Hernandez, Natalie, Ma, Stephanie, Mao, Yamini, Naidu, Tuukka, Miinalainen, Marion Aruann, Daniel Calendini, Yoann Chabert, Gael Chambonnier, Myriam, Choukour, Ella de Gaulejac, Camille, Houy, Axel, Levier, Loreen, Logger, Sebastien, Nin, Valerie, Prima, Sturgis, James N., Beibei, Fang, Sadik, Cigdem, Abdullah, Ucar, Alejandro, Gutierrez, Revanth, Poondla, Sanjana, Reddy, Tyler, Rocha, Natalie, Schulte, Devin, Wehle, Marta Eva Jackowski, Sean Ross Craig, Ariana Mirzarafie Ahi, Elliott, Parris, Luba, Prout, Barbara, Steijl, Rachel, Wellman, Zhao, Fan, Zhang, Jing, Yang, Wei, Yang, Yuanzhan, Wen, Zhaosen, Evan, Appletion, Jeffrey, Chen, Abha, Patil, Shaheer, Priracha, Kate, Ryan, Nick, Salvador, John, Viola, Boralli, Camila Maria S., Camila Barbosa Bramorski, Juliana Cancino Bernardi, Ana Laura de Lima, Paula Maria Pincela Lins, Cristiane Casonato Melo, Deborah Cezar Mendonca, Thiago, Mosqueiro, Everton, Silva, Graziele, Vasconcelos, Ruchi, Asthana, Donna, Lee, Michelle, Yu, Peter, Choi, Effie, Lau, Kenneth, Lau, Oscar, Ying, Brandon, Malone, Paul, Young, Aidan, Ceney, Dakota, Hawthorne, Sharon, Lian, Sam, Mellentine, Dylan, Miller, Barbara Castro Moreira, Christie, Peebles, Olivia, Smith, Kevin, Walsh, Allison, Zimont, Michael, Brasino, Michael, Donovan, Hannah, Young, Jan, Bejvl, Daniel, Georgiev, Hynek, Kasl, Katerina Pechotova, Vaclav Pelisek, Anna, Sosnova, Pavel, Zach, Anthony, Ciesla, Benjamin, Hoover, Elliott, Chapman, Jon Marles Wright, Vicky, Moynihan, Liusaidh, Owen, Brooke Rothschild Mancinelli, Emilie, Cuillery, Joseph, Heng, Vincent, Jacquot, Paola, Malsot, Rocco, Meli, Cyril, Pulver, Ari, Sarfatis, Loic, Steiner, Victor, Steininger, Nina van Tiel, Gregoire, Thouvenin, Axel, Uran, Lisa, Baumgartner, Anna, Fomitcheva, Daniel, Gerngross, Verena, Jagger, Michael, Meier, Anja, Michel, Jasmine, Bird, Bradley, Brown, Todd, Burlington, Daniel, Herring, Joseph, Slack, Georgina, Westwood, Emilia, Wojcik, Julian, Bender, Julia, Donauer, Ramona, Emig, Rabea, Jesser, Julika, Neumann, Lara, Stuhn, Takema, Hasegawa, Tomoya, Kozakai, Haruka, Maruyama, Sean, Colloms, Charlotte, Flynn, Vilija, Lomeikaite, James, Provan, Kang, Ning, Shuyan, Tang, Guozhao, Wu, Yunjun, Yang, Zhi, Zeng, Zhan, Yi, Pan, Chu, Jun, Li, Keji, Yan, Athale, Chaitanya A., Swapnil, Bodkhe, Manasi, Gangan, Harsh, Gakhare, Yash, Jawale, Snehal, Kadam, Prachiti, Moghe, Gayatri, Mundhe, Neha, Khetan, Ira, Phadke, Prashant, Uniyal, Siddhesh, Zadey, Ines, Cottignie, Eline, Deprez, Astrid, Deryckere, Jasper, Janssens, Frederik, Jonnaert, Katarzyna, Malczewska, Thomas, Pak, Johan, Robben, Ovia Margaret Thirukkumaran, Vincent Van Deuren, Laurens, Vandebroek, Laura Van Hese, Laetitia Van Wonterghem, Leen, Verschooten, Moritz, Wolter, Joss, Auty, Richard, Badge, Liam, Crawford, Raymond, Dalgleish, Amy, Evans, Cameron, Grundy, Charlie, Kruczko, Payal, Karia, Graeme, Glaister, Rhys, Hakstol, Seme, Mate, Karin, Otero, Dustin, Smith, Jeff, Tingley, Hans Joachim Wieden, Haotian, Wang, Ningning, Yao, Matthias, Franz, Anna, Knoerlein, Nicolas, Koutsoubelis, Loechner, Anne C., Max, Mundt, Alexandra, Richter, Oliver, Schauer, Marjorie, Buss, Sivateja, Tangirala, Brian, Teague, Tianyi, Huang, Xinhao, Song, Yibing, Wei, Zhaoran, Zhang, Longzhi, Cao, Cheng Li, Kang Yang, Zhiqin, Chen, Yuxing, Fang, Libo, Sun, Weiyi, Wang, Yang, Yang, David, Adams, Joshua, Colls, Joshua, Timmons, David, Urick, Julia Anna Adrian, Madina, Akan, Youssef, Chahibi, Rahmi, Lale, Typhaine Le Doujet, Marit Vaagen Roee, Altynay, Abdirakhmanova, Askarbek, Orakov, Azhar, Zhailauova, Jinyang, Liang, Yu, Ma, Qikai, Qin, Yetian, Su, Ju Yeon Han, Raphaella, Hull, Wei Chung Kong, Li Chieh Lu, Duke, Quinton, Pauline, Aubert, Johan, Bourdarias, Olivier, Bugaud, Coralie Demon Chaine, Isabelle, Hatin, Ibtissam Kaid Slimane, Seong Koo Kang, Audrey, Moatti, Cheikh Fall Ndiaye, Mathilde, Ananos, Alexander, Arkhipenko, Valentin, Bailly, Jules, Caput, Javier, Castillo, Alma Chapet Batlle, Floriane, Cherrier, Claudia Demarta Gatsi, Deshmukh, Gopaul, Muriel, Gugger, Caroline, Lambert, Lucas, Krauss, Amelie, Vandendaele, Xiaojing, Li, Lin, Xiaomei, Luo Xunxun, Anders C. h. r. Hansen, Tina, Kronborg, Pettersen, Jens S., Charles, Calvet, Tyler Dae Devlin, Kosuke, Fujishima, Danny, Greenberg, Tina, Ju, Ryan, Kent, Daniel, Kunin, Erica, Lieberman, Griffin, Mccutcheon, Thai, Nguyen, Lynn, Rothschild, Shih, Joseph D., Jack, Takahashi, Kirsten, Thompson, Forrest, Tran, Daniel, Xiang, Felix, Richter, Yang, Xiaoran, Xiangyue, Hu, Changyuan, Deng, Shuyu, Hua, Yumeng, Li, Xinyu, Meng, Boxiang, Wang, Yingqi, Wang, Xuan, Wang, Zixuan, Xu, Jieyu, Yan, Ming, Yan, Yineng, Zhou, Edgar Alberto Alcalá Orozco, José Alberto Cristerna Bermúdez, Daniela Flores Gómez, José Ernesto Hernández Castañeda, Diana Clarisse Montaño Navarro, Juana Yessica PérezÁvila, María Fernanda Salazar Figueroa, María Fernanda Sánchez Arroyo, Oliva Angélica Sánchez Montesinos, Ángel Farid Rojas Cruz, Carlos Ramos Gutiérrez, Alonso Pérez Lona, Carlos Alejandro Meza Ramírez, Fernanda Sotomayor Olivares, Jorge Sebastián Rodríguez Iniesta, Juan Carlos Rueda Silva, Shotaro, Ayukawa, Takahiro, Kashiwagi, Daisuke, Kiga, Misa, Minegishi, Riku, Shinohara, Hiraku, Tokuma, Yuta, Yamazaki, Shuhei, Yasunishi, Erinn Sim Zixuan, Remsha, Afzal, Matthew, Carrigan, Barry, Moran, Marlena, Mucha, Arnas, Petrauskas, Stefan, Marsden, Michelle, Post, Anne, Rodenburg, Hector, Sanguesa, Marit van der Does, Erwin van Rijn, Max van’t Hof, Yeshi de Bruin, Hans de Ferrante, Elles, Elschot, Laura, Jacobs, Jan Willem Muller, Sjoerd, Nooijens, Femke, Vaassen, Cas van der Putten, Esther van Leeuwen, Laura van Smeden, Kwan Kwan Zhu, Kevin, Sabath, Katharina, Sporbeck, Nicolai von Kügelgen, Lisa, Wellinger, Stefanie, Braun, Jack, Ho, Yash, Mishra, Mariola, Sebastian, Lucas von Chamier, Ahsan, Fasih M., Satyadi, Megan A., Vivienne, Gunadhi, Phillip, Kyriakakis, Jenny, Lee, Walter, Thavarajah, Kimia, Abtahi, Robert, Hand, Chun Mun Loke, Adam, Wahab, Iowis, Zhu, Del Bianco, Cristina, Chizzolini, Fabio, Elisa, Godino, Lentini, Roberta, Mansy, Sheref Samir, Yeh Martin, Noel, Claudio Oss Pegorar, Alexander, Cook, Timothy, Kerns, Chad, Nielsen, Michael, Paskett, Alexander, Torgesen, Stephen, Lee, Ophir, Ospovat, Sikandar, Raza, Daniel, Shaykevich, Jarrod, Shilts, Barbora, Bajorinaite, Mykolas, Bendorius, Ieva, Rauluseviciute, Ieva, Savickyte, Sarunas, Tumas, William, Buchser, Elli, Cryan, Caroline, Golino, Andrew, Halleran, Taylor, Jacobs, Michael, Lefew, Joe, Maniaci, John, Marken, Margaret, Saha, Panya, Vij, Kayla, Desanty, Julie, Mazza
Přispěvatelé: Raytheon BBN Technologies, iGEM Foundation, Synthace, Agilent Technology [Santa Clara], Raytheon BBN Technologies, Synthace, and Agilent provided support in the form of salaries for authors JB, MG, and JH, but did not have any additional role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. The specific roles of these authors are articulated in the author contributions section, The authors wish to thank Sarah Munro and Marc Salit of NIST for help in designing this study. Consortium authors include all persons self-identified by contributing teams as deserving co-authorship credit. Contributors are listed alphabetically within team, and teams alphabetically and by year. Note that some persons may be credited as contributing in both years. Team names are given as identified in iGEM records: full details of each team’s institution and additional members may be found online in the iGEM Foundation archives at:http://year.igem.org/Team:name e.g.: full information on the 2015 ETH_Zurich team may be found at: http://2015.igem.org/Team:ETH_Zurich, BBN Technologies, IGEM Foundation, Synthace Ltd., Agilent Technologies, Department of Biotechnology and Chemical Technology, Helsinki Institute for Information Technology HIIT, ATOMS Turkiye, Boston University, Carnegie Mellon University, Technical University of Denmark, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, Middle East Technical University, Sumbawa University of Technology, Southern University of Science and Technology, Sun Yat-Sen University, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Universidad Autonoma de Nuevo Leon, University of Ottawa, Universitat Politècnica de València, Wageningen University and Research Centre, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Xiamen University, University of Texas at Austin, Bielefeld University, Birkbeck University of London, USP-Brazil, City University of Hong Kong, Colorado State University, CU Boulder, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich, University of Exeter, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, KU Leuven, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Northeast Agricultural University, Nanjing Agricultural University, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Ocean University of China, University of Southern Denmark, Shenzhen Middle School - SZMS 15, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Trinity College Dublin, Delft University of Technology, Eindhoven University of Technology, Tuebingen, University of California Los Angeles, University of California San Diego, University of Maryland, University of Trento, Vanderbilt University, College of William and Mary, Department of Bioproducts and Biosystems, Aalto-yliopisto, Aalto University, Jones, D Dafydd, Discrete Technology and Production Automation, ​Robotics and image-guided minimally-invasive surgery (ROBOTICS)
Jazyk: angličtina
Rok vydání: 2016
Předmět:
0106 biological sciences
0301 basic medicine
green fluorescent protein
Laboratory Proficiency Testing
Transcription
Genetic

International Genetically Engineered Machine
[SDV]Life Sciences [q-bio]
lcsh:Medicine
Protein Engineering
01 natural sciences
Infographics
Synthetic biology
genetics
lcsh:Science
Promoter Regions
Genetic

Macromolecular Engineering
transcription initiation
Measurement
Multidisciplinary
Chemistry
Strain (biology)
gene expression regulation
good laboratory practice
Research Assessment
Fluorescence
Reproducibility
3. Good health
Bioassays and Physiological Analysis
Engineering and Technology
Educational Status
Synthetic Biology
Genetic Engineering
Transcription
Graphs
Research Article
Biotechnology
Transcriptional Activation
Computer and Information Sciences
General Science & Technology
Green Fluorescent Proteins
Bioengineering
Computational biology
iGEM Interlab Study Contributors
Research and Analysis Methods
Promoter Regions
03 medical and health sciences
promoter region
Genetic
010608 biotechnology
Escherichia coli
ta215
business.industry
Data Visualization
lcsh:R
Fluorescence Competition
genetic transcription
DNA structure
Reproducibility of Results
Biology and Life Sciences
protein engineering
030104 developmental biology
Good Health and Well Being
7 INGENIERÍA Y TECNOLOGÍA
Synthetic Bioengineering
People and Places
lcsh:Q
Population Groupings
biosynthesis
business
metabolism
Undergraduates
Zdroj: PLoS ONE
PLoS ONE, Public Library of Science, 2016, 11 (3), pp.e0150182. ⟨10.1371/journal.pone.0150182⟩
PloS one, vol 11, iss 3
BASE-Bielefeld Academic Search Engine
PLoS ONE, Vol 11, Iss 3, p e0150182 (2016)
PLOS ONE
PLoS ONE, 11(3):e0150182. PUBLIC LIBRARY SCIENCE
PLoS ONE, 11 (3)
ISSN: 1932-6203
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0150182⟩
Popis: We present results of the first large-scale interlaboratory study carried out in synthetic biology, as part of the 2014 and 2015 International Genetically Engineered Machine (iGEM) competitions. Participants at 88 institutions around the world measured fluorescence from three engineered constitutive constructs in E. coli. Few participants were able to measure absolute fluorescence, so data was analyzed in terms of ratios. Precision was strongly related to fluorescent strength, ranging from 1.54-fold standard deviation for the ratio between strong promoters to 5.75-fold for the ratio between the strongest and weakest promoter, and while host strain did not affect expression ratios, choice of instrument did. This result shows that high quantitative precision and reproducibility of results is possible, while at the same time indicating areas needing improved laboratory practices. Copyright: © 2016 Beal et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Databáze: OpenAIRE