Evaluation of development strategies and community needs in developing countries: A comparative case study of informal settlements in Asia and Africa

Autor: Guido Conaldi, Aya Magdi Awad, Deborah Bartlett
Přispěvatelé: Trapani, Ferdinando, Mohareb, Nabil, Rosso, Federica, Kolokotsa, Denia, Maruthaveeran, Sreetheran, Ghoneem, Mahmoud
Jazyk: angličtina
Rok vydání: 2021
Předmět:
Zdroj: Advanced Studies in Efficient Environmental Design and City Planning ISBN: 9783030651800
ISSN: 2522-8714
Popis: From the millennium development goals (MDGs) to the sustainable development goals (SDGs), social inclusion has been highlighted as an aspect to consider while developing urban areas. Progress has been witnessed to various degrees in developing countries. However, low-income communities have generally experienced a set of operational setbacks (Cobbinah et al. in Environ Dev 13:18–32, 2015). For instance, official development proposals have not met community needs, and assistance promised had not been provided (Sachs in The Lancet 379(9832):2206–2211, 2012). Basic needs are fundamental to sustainable development schemes, and Governments should develop strategies to ensure that basic needs are met. As stated in Brundtland report, “Sustainable development requires meeting the basic needs of all and extending to all the opportunity to satisfy their aspirations for a better life” (World Commission on Environment and Development in Report of the World Commission on environment and development: our common future, p. 16, 1987). This includes the provision of adequate food, energy, housing, sanitation, employment, water supply and health care. Satisfying these needs at community level will ultimately provide a better life for individuals (Holden et al. in Glob Environ Change 26:130–139, 2014). Informal settlements—or slum areas—are a common occurrence in developing countries. This phenomenon results from the migration of people from rural to urban areas looking for better opportunities to overcome poverty. Informal settlements play a significant role in the housing market as affordable housing schemes are often not attainable within the budget of a large section of the population. Furthermore, affordable accommodation rarely meets the requirements of the community (Hassan in Alexandria Eng J 51(3):229–239, 2012; Naceur in Front Architectural Res 2(4):400–408, 2013). This leads to the potential conflict between informal settlement communities, land government authorities and bordering societies (Lombard and Rakodi in Urban Stud 53(13):2683–2699, 2016). Moore’s strategic triangle model of the public policy states that a balanced strategy for an appropriate governance framework should comprise democratic legitimacy and government support, with community endorsement. In addition, adequate operational capacity is required to deliver development schemes that satisfy informal settlement resident’s needs (Kavanagh in Gov Finance Rev 4, 2014; Moore in Nonprofit Voluntary Sect Q 29(1_suppl):183–204, 2000). This paper compares informal settlements in Africa and Asia to identify what factors influence community satisfaction and, based on this makes, recommendations to inform future proposals for the redevelopment of informal settlements.
Databáze: OpenAIRE