Life under Wainwright v. Witt: Juror dispositions and death qualification

Autor: Ronald C. Dillehay, Marla Sandys
Rok vydání: 1996
Předmět:
Zdroj: Law and Human Behavior. 20:147-165
ISSN: 1573-661X
0147-7307
DOI: 10.1007/bf01499352
Popis: The current standard for determining juror qualification in cases in which the prosecution is seeking the death penalty was formulated by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1985 inWainwright v. Witt. This standard differs importantly from its predecessor, and requires that prospective jurors be dismissed if their views would prevent or substantially impair their ability to perform their functions as jurors. We assessed respondents according to the criteria imposed byWitt. We also measured independently prospective juror's abilities to perform the various specific tasks of a capital juror and their disposition to impose the death penalty automatically upon defendants convicted of murder punishable by death. Data from 148 respondents, selected randomly from juries on previously tried felony cases, indicated that 28.2% of those includable by theWitt standard would automatically impose the death penalty. Considering all respondents who would be erroneously included or excluded, a total of 36% of the sample showed inconsistencies with theWitt criterion. These findings are discussed in terms of jurors' difficulties in anticipating their roles as capital jurors.
Databáze: OpenAIRE
Externí odkaz: