In pursuit of sustainability in dairy farming: A review of interdependent effects of animal welfare improvement and environmental impact mitigation

Autor: Anna Herzog, Werner Zollitsch, Christoph Winckler
Rok vydání: 2018
Předmět:
Zdroj: Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment. 267:174-187
ISSN: 0167-8809
DOI: 10.1016/j.agee.2018.07.029
Popis: The welfare of dairy cows and their emission potential are two distinct and yet intertwined aspects determining the sustainability of dairy farming. Along with numerous measures to mitigate the sector’s environmental impact, good health and welfare are suggested to keep emission levels low. More recently, scientists in both fields have pointed to potential trade-offs for animal welfare arising from the implementation of environmental impact mitigation measures. Research has since focused on the qualitative evaluation of these welfare implications, but little is known about the actual magnitude of the effects on welfare of emission mitigating measures. Moreover, potential environmental impacts associated with welfare improvement measures have hardly been investigated so far, although estimates of respective increases in emission levels associated with various cattle diseases suggest the importance of welfare improvement in pursuit of integral sustainability improvement in dairy farming. For a comprehensive enhancement of the sector’s sustainability, a careful balancing of interdependent effects is thus suggested. This review aims at providing the first inclusive overview on measures of both greenhouse-gas and ammonia emission mitigation and welfare improvement relevant in terms of respective interdependencies. Derived from the literature in both fields, attempts are also made to quantitatively evaluate the interdependent effects. Our findings confirm, that mitigation measures such as breeding for increased genetic yield potential, the use of rumen modifiers and the increase of concentrate ratio in the diet are potentially harmful for the animals’ health and welfare, while an increased amount of fat in the diet and the adaptation of the protein ratio to the yield level offer welfare neutral mitigation potential. By contrasting frequently suggested welfare improvement measures with determinants of emission formation, we identified the increase of space allowance and cleanliness, as well as temperature management and access to pasture as welfare measures with potential environmental impact. As for the evaluation of interdependencies, we found that to some extent a quantification of trade-offs is possible for welfare relevant health disorders, such as lameness and mastitis, for which both the effect of welfare improvement measures on their prevalence and an impact range in terms of emissions have already been described in literature. Although further research is needed for a comprehensive balancing of trade-offs, we conclude, that a careful distinction between the effect of an improvement measure and the effect of its impact as suggested in this review may serve as a basis for further research and improve decision-making in dairy farming in terms of sustainability.
Databáze: OpenAIRE
Externí odkaz: