The 'Closure' Assumption as a First Step: Neo-Ricardian Economics and Post-Keynesianism

Autor: Stephen Pratten
Rok vydání: 1996
Předmět:
Zdroj: Review of Social Economy. 54:423-443
ISSN: 1470-1162
0034-6764
DOI: 10.1080/00346769600000027
Popis: In this paper I accept that just as mainstream economics can be characterized by its insistence upon a deductivist method, so the least contentious, most widely accepted aspects of Post-Keynesianism can be accounted for by its anti-deductivist stance and more specifically by its tacit commitment to something like critical realism. I argue that neo- Ricardian economics, to the extent that it takes closure for granted as a natural and useful starting point for analysis, retains an underlying commitment to deductivism and so is difficult to reconcile with Post- Keynesianism. By providing a criterion for assessing whether neo- Ricardianism belongs within a coherent Post-Keynesianism I also clarify why the nature of this rclationship has for so long remained unresolved. Not until it was recognized that coherence within Post-Keynesianism turns upon methodological issues, and essentially involves the abandon- ment of the deductivist framework, could progress in understanding its relationship with neo-Ri...
Databáze: OpenAIRE