| Popis: |
The COVID-19 pandemic has co-existed alongside a far less visible "shadow pandemic" of violence against women, with COVID-19 impacting the number and complexity of domestic violence cases and enabling new tactics for coercive control This article provides a preliminary assessment of the extent to which Canada's responses to the COVID-19 pandemic have prioritized the safety of women and children, with a focus on the courts and women's access to justice We examine court directives and judicial decisions triaging which cases would be heard as "urgent," as well as courts' decisions on the merits in cases involving domestic violence and COVID-19, spanning the areas of family, child welfare, criminal law, and civil protection orders In the sixty-seven reported decisions in our sample, we find very little awareness overall of the heightened risks for survivors during COVID-19, in keeping with the pre-pandemic tendency of decision makers to focus on incident-based physical violence instead of patterns of coercive control Our analysis also suggests that survivors' ability to prove domestic violence and secure court orders that would help to ensure their safety was hampered not only by procedural complexity but also by the reduced availability of a range of services-health, counselling, housing, and supervised access centres, for example-as a result of COVID-19 The cases further reveal significant differences in judicial interpretation of the risks of COVID-19 relative to the risks of domestic violence, often depending on the area of law in question This again aligns with observations of the judicial treatment of domestic violence prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, with different and sometimes conflicting norms and assumptions prevailing in different legal contexts We conclude that despite some positive government responses and judicial decisions, COVID-19 has further exposed many of the gaps in knowledge about domestic violence and in the supports and resources necessary to make women and children safe that long pre-dated COVID-19 In addressing the ongoing pandemic of violence against women, we offer some suggestions of measures to improve access to justice during this and future disasters |
