On Conceptual Entropy: Metaphors We Die From.

Autor: Hvidtfeldt, Rolf, Pedersen, David Budtz
Předmět:
Zdroj: Danish Yearbook of Philosophy; 2024, Vol. 57 Issue 1, p116-133, 18p
Abstrakt: This paper explores the implications of conceptual entropy in interdisciplinary collaboration, examining perspectives from philosophy and contemporary social science. Conceptual entropy, the degree of disorder in a conceptual system, is analyzed from the viewpoints of those advocating for reducing ambiguity to achieve scientific precision, as well as those advocating for embracing ambiguity to reflect real-world complexity. We aim to demonstrate the need for conceptual clarity and thereby criticize deliberate conceptual vagueness. Semantic vagueness may arise due to fuzzy ontological mechanisms guarding the relevant object domain. However, vagueness may also result from the unwarranted use of metaphors. We address the risk of precision loss in interdisciplinary teams by proposing a framework for studying conceptual entropy. On this basis, we argue that 'conceptual entropy' is useful for reflecting on how unclear, messy, and ambivalent concepts and conceptual systems may lead to an accelerating state of semantic disorder and vagueness. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
Databáze: Complementary Index