Editorial Reflections on Open Review: Leveling the Playing Field?

Autor: Adamson, John L., Nunn, Roger C.
Předmět:
Zdroj: English Scholarship Beyond Borders; 2023, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p4-13, 10p
Abstrakt: In this study we investigated review interaction between supervising editors, reviewers and authors engaged in Open Review at the journal English Scholarship beyond Borders in the field of applied linguistics and TESOL. Analyzing our interactional review discourse, survey data and literature from studies in other fields into Open Review, we concluded that the initial principles of 'leveling the playing field' though unblinded reviewing among participants met with some approval, but that important lessons were to be learned about relative positioning in the field and recognition of advances in journal OR practices from other disciplines. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
Databáze: Complementary Index