Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Theories of Continuity in Physics VI.

Autor: MARINCA, Andrei
Předmět:
Zdroj: Hermeneia: Journal of Hermeneutics, Art Theory & Criticism; 2022, Issue 28, p38-51, 14p
Abstrakt: This paper examines Aristotle‟s criticism of the Presocratic atomistic theories of physical continuity. In order to assess Aristotle‟s account of these theories, I first supply a description of Leucippus‟ and Democritus‟ atomism, as their doctrines can be reconstructed from textual fragments. Next, I follow modern exegesis in linking the pluralistic physics of the atomists with the core of issues developed in the Eleatic school. I will analyse Zeno‟s paradoxes as presented by Aristotle and I will consider Aristotle‟s own arguments against atomism (Physics VI), which provided a blueprint for most of the antiatomistic critiques in pre-modern times and represented a challenge for any subsequent defender of atomism. Discussing Pyle‟s, Furley‟s, and Vlastos‟ accounts of these arguments, I intend to clarify the philosophical implications of the paradoxes which arose from the first discussions on continuity in the history of philosophy. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
Databáze: Complementary Index