Levels or Domains of Life?
Autor: | Pranab K. Das, Anton Markoš |
---|---|
Rok vydání: | 2016 |
Předmět: |
0301 basic medicine
Value (ethics) Philosophy of science Process (engineering) Communication Field (Bourdieu) 05 social sciences 050905 science studies Language and Linguistics Epistemology 03 medical and health sciences 030104 developmental biology Three-domain system Semiotics Natural (music) Sociology 0509 other social sciences Social Sciences (miscellaneous) Reciprocal |
Zdroj: | Biosemiotics. 9:319-330 |
ISSN: | 1875-1350 1875-1342 |
DOI: | 10.1007/s12304-016-9271-6 |
Popis: | In the case of living beings – the very concept of “level” of organization becomes obscure: it suggests a value-based assessment, assigning notions like “lower” and “higher” with rather vague criteria for constructing the ladder of perfection, complexity, importance, etc. We prefer therefore the term “domain”, entities ranking equal. Domains may represent natural entities as well as purely human constructs developed in order to gain understanding of some facets of living things; living, evolved beings (e.g. viviparous animals, eukaryotic cells, etc.) as well as those abstract constructs, such as genotype and ‘niche’ which have been developed in the search for better understanding of such living things. Delimitation of such domains is sometimes a question of the dexterity of the researcher, and sometimes draws from the tradition in a given field. Such domains are not completely (canonically) translatable to each other. Rather, they interact by a process that we call here reciprocal formation. Life (including the biosphere and human cultures which are emergent within the frame of the biosphere) is unique among multi-domain systems. In contrast to purely physical systems, life is a semiotic system driven by the historical experience of lineages, interpreted and re-interpreted by the incessant turnover of both individuals and their communities. This paper provides cases of domain interrelations, and addresses two questions: (1) How do new qualities of inter-domain interaction emerge historically? (2) How do new domains (ways of understanding the world) emerge in evolution. Two approaches, physical and biosemiotic, are discussed as we seek to get a better understanding of the overarching tasks. |
Databáze: | OpenAIRE |
Externí odkaz: |